Emergency CDL Rule Threatens to Paralyze Supply Chains as 200,000 Drivers Face License Loss

BREAKING: Sean Duffy Announces New CDL Rules 'Effective Immediately,' Action Against CA - YouTube

 Federal action following fatal crashes could severely disrupt trucking industry already facing critical shortages

The Federal Motor Carrier Safety Administration's emergency rule restricting commercial driver's licenses for foreign nationals threatens to remove nearly 200,000 drivers from America's roads, potentially paralyzing supply chains already strained by critical driver shortages and port congestion.

Transportation Secretary Sean Duffy announced the sweeping reforms Friday following what he characterized as a "catastrophic failure" by states to properly issue licenses to foreign drivers. The immediate restrictions come after five fatal crashes this year involving non-domiciled CDL holders killed 12 people and injured 15 others, prompting federal officials to declare a "national emergency."

Massive Driver Exodus Expected

The emergency rule affects approximately 200,000 current non-domiciled CDL holders and 20,000 commercial learner's permit holders, with FMCSA expecting 194,000 won't qualify under new restrictions within two years. The timing couldn't be worse for an industry already grappling with a shortage of 80,000 drivers nationwide.

The rule, effective immediately upon publication in the Federal Register on Sept. 29, limits non-domiciled CDL eligibility to foreign nationals holding H-2A agricultural worker visas, H-2B temporary non-agricultural worker visas, or E-2 treaty investor visas. FMCSA estimates only about 6,000 drivers annually will qualify for non-domiciled credentials under the new restrictions, representing a dramatic reduction in eligible applicants.

Supply Chain Paralysis Looms

The potential loss of 200,000 drivers represents nearly 5% of the nation's commercial driver workforce and threatens to severely disrupt supply chains. The trucking sector moves 71% of all U.S. goods, with over 164,000 miles of highways relying heavily on trucks for agricultural products, retail goods, and industrial materials.

Port Operations at Risk: California's ports handle 40% of the nation's containerized imports, but the state faces the most severe enforcement action. FMCSA found that more than 25% of non-domiciled CDLs in California were improperly issued, with some licenses extending as many as four years beyond drivers' authorized presence. The agency has given California 30 days to comply or face the loss of $160 million in federal highway funding.

TWIC Card Enforcement: Port access requires Transportation Worker Identification Credentials (TWIC), creating an additional enforcement mechanism. TWIC cards are required by the Maritime Transportation Security Act for workers needing access to secure areas of maritime facilities, and non-U.S. citizens in certain immigrant/non-immigrant categories may apply. However, employers must retrieve TWIC cards from applicants when work visas expire and return them to TSA, creating an immediate enforcement tool at ports.

California-Federal Standoff Intensifies

The confrontation between California and federal authorities threatens to trigger immediate supply chain disruptions. California Governor Gavin Newsom's office has pushed back against federal claims, arguing that commercial driver's license holders from California have a significantly lower crash rate than both the national average and Texas.

The standoff creates uncertainty for shippers and carriers operating nationwide routes. California licenses allow drivers to operate in all 50 states, meaning improperly issued licenses affect roads nationwide. If California refuses to comply and federal funding is withheld, the resulting infrastructure deterioration could compound supply chain problems.

Western States Face Domino Effect

Beyond California, FMCSA identified similar violations in Colorado, Pennsylvania, South Dakota, Texas, and Washington, with enforcement actions pending. The concentration of violations in western states—key conduits for Pacific trade—amplifies potential disruptions to import/export operations.

Port Vulnerability: The current driver shortage affects all modes of trucking, with port drayage particularly vulnerable. Undocumented workers previously made up a substantial part of the drayage workforce at Los Angeles and Long Beach ports until post-9/11 security measures required TWIC cards.

Economic Ripple Effects: Meanwhile, market interruptions can halt or dramatically slow shipping of non-essential goods, clogging ports and creating massive shipping backlogs up and down the supply chain. The U.S. lacks high-speed rail alternatives, making road transport indispensable.

Industry Pushback and Reality Check

Some industry experts dispute the severity of claimed driver shortages. Port of Los Angeles Executive Director Gene Seroka has stated: "In Southern California, we don't have a shortage of truckers. We have a shortage of good jobs. More than 660,000 commercial driver's licenses have been issued in California, yet we could probably use 3,000 to 5,000 more drivers at our port complex."

Critics argue that blaming supply chain problems on trucker shortages enables companies to recruit more people and charge them for school, only for students to realize trucking isn't a desirable profession due to poor working conditions.

However, the sudden removal of 200,000 drivers would create immediate capacity constraints regardless of underlying industry dynamics. When carriers rush to play catch-up, more trucks are demanded to keep up with goods needing shipment. With fewer drivers available due to shortage and fewer trucks available due to high demand, carrier capacity can quickly become maxed out.

Enforcement at Maritime Facilities

The rule's immediate impact will be felt most acutely at ports, where TWIC card requirements create enforceable checkpoints. Workers requiring unescorted access to secure port areas must obtain TWIC cards, including truck drivers accessing maritime facilities. Without TWIC cards, drivers must pay for authorized escorts and face significant delays, additional security clearances, and extra fees.

Port terminals can immediately identify non-compliant drivers through TWIC card scanning systems. Trucking companies report that terminal employees scan drivers' TWIC card numbers, and carriers face bans of 30 to 180 days for violations, with no due process for appeals.

Fatal Crashes Drive Action

The emergency rule follows a series of deadly incidents involving improperly licensed drivers:

March 14, 2025 - Texas: A truck driver failed to brake and crashed into traffic, causing a 17-vehicle pileup that killed five people, including two children. The driver had a history of unsafe lane changes and multiple service violations.

May 6, 2025 - Alabama: A driver with six weeks' experience struck four vehicles at a red light, killing two people on his third day of employment after failing skills tests for speeding.

August 12, 2025 - Florida: Harjinder Singh made an illegal U-turn on Florida's Turnpike, killing three people. Singh failed an English proficiency test after the crash, answering just 2 of 12 verbal questions correctly and identifying only 1 of 4 highway signs.

Economic Stakes

In 2022, the trucking industry generated $940.8 billion in gross freight revenues, accounting for 80.7% of the U.S. transportation industry. The potential disruption comes as the industry faces multiple pressures, including aging infrastructure, rising fuel costs, and regulatory changes.

The American Trucking Associations reported a shortage of 80,000 drivers in 2021, with estimates reaching 115,000 in 2025 and projections exceeding 170,000 drivers by 2030. The emergency rule's removal of 200,000 drivers would more than double the existing shortage.

Industry Response

The American Trucking Associations and Owner-Operator Independent Drivers Association have praised the crackdown. "Loopholes in this program have allowed unqualified drivers onto America's highways, creating unnecessary safety risks for professional drivers and the motoring public," said OOIDA President Todd Spencer.

However, the sudden implementation without transition period has raised concerns about immediate operational impacts. The rule includes a 60-day comment period for public input, though its immediate effective date remains in place.

Looking Ahead

Secretary Duffy indicated this is "just the beginning," with enforcement actions against other states forthcoming. All states must immediately pause non-domiciled CDL issuance until demonstrating compliance with new requirements.

The confrontation between federal authorities and states like California could determine whether the rule achieves its safety goals or creates economic chaos. With the holiday shipping season approaching and supply chains already strained, the stakes couldn't be higher for America's freight transportation system.

California's Defiant Response

California has shown limited willingness to comply, with a spokesperson for Governor Gavin Newsom saying the state "will respond to the letter in due course" while defending California's safety record. "California commercial driver's license holders had a fatal crash rate nearly 40% LOWER than the national average," said Diana Crofts-Pelayo, the governor's Deputy Director of Communications. "Texas — the only state with more commercial holders — has a rate almost 50% higher than California."

The California Department of Motor Vehicles told Overdrive it "complies with FMCSA regulations and is cooperating with the U.S. Department of Transportation on the audit." However, this cooperation appears limited, as California previously told Overdrive it does not track how many CDLs it issues to non-citizens, yet FMCSA investigators found hard numbers showing more than 60,000 non-domiciled CDLs issued in California last year with potentially 15,000 done improperly.

California's resistance reflects a broader pattern of confrontation with the Trump administration. The state has filed 37 lawsuits against federal actions and claims to have "restored at least $168 billion in federal funding" through legal challenges. Governor Newsom has characterized federal actions as attacks on California, setting up a constitutional battle over state versus federal authority.

DOT's Escalating Enforcement Powers

FMCSA possesses significant enforcement tools to compel state compliance, following a progressive escalation process:

Immediate Actions:

• 4% of federal highway funding withheld in the first year ($160 million for California)
• Funding withholding doubles in the second year
• Mandatory pause of all non-domicile CDL issuance until compliance

Ultimate Sanction - Program Decertification: Under 49 U.S.C. § 31312, FMCSA has the authority to decertify states found to be in substantial non-compliance with CDL requirements from issuing CDLs altogether. This would mean California could lose the right to issue any commercial driver's licenses, forcing all California truckers to obtain licenses from other states.

Legal Framework: Under 49 U.S.C. § 31314, if during FMCSA's annual review a state is found in substantial non-compliance, FMCSA shall withhold amounts from the state's apportionment of Title 23 Federal-aid Highway funding beginning the first fiscal year following the first fiscal year of substantial non-compliance.

Federal Supremacy: The federal government's authority over interstate commerce and highway safety gives DOT significant leverage. States depend heavily on federal highway funding for infrastructure maintenance and improvements, making funding withdrawal a powerful enforcement mechanism.

Potential Standoff Scenarios

If California refuses to comply within 30 days, several scenarios could unfold:

Economic Pressure: Loss of $160 million in highway funding would force California to choose between compliance and using state funds to replace federal money, straining the state budget.

Legal Challenge: California could challenge the emergency rule in federal court, arguing it violates due process or exceeds federal authority, potentially creating a lengthy legal battle while supply chain disruptions continue.

Complete Decertification: If funding withdrawal fails to achieve compliance, DOT could decertify California's entire CDL program, creating chaos for the state's 640,000+ CDL holders and devastating port operations.

Constitutional Crisis: A prolonged standoff could escalate into a broader constitutional confrontation over federal versus state authority, similar to historical conflicts over civil rights enforcement.

The outcome will determine whether federal safety regulations can be effectively enforced against resistant states, with implications extending far beyond trucking to the balance of federal-state power and the integrity of national transportation systems.

---

California DMV Reform: How the System Could Meet New Federal Requirements

California's current non-domicile CDL process relies on Employment Authorization Documents (EADs) and I-94 forms to verify legal presence, but the new federal emergency rule requires much stricter verification and documentation standards.

Current California Process

Under existing procedures, California DMV accepts:

• Unexpired Employment Authorization Document (EAD) issued by USCIS
• Unexpired foreign passport with approved I-94 Arrival/Departure Record
• Various temporary legal status documents

The state uses the federal SAVE (Systematic Alien Verification for Entitlements) system to verify immigration status, but this verification often occurs after initial license issuance and can take 3-5 seconds for automated verification, 3-5 working days for secondary verification, or up to 40 federal workdays for manual review.

Required Reforms Under Emergency Rule

To comply with new federal standards, California would need to implement:

Enhanced Eligibility Screening:

• Accept only H-2A agricultural visas, H-2B temporary non-agricultural visas, or E-2 treaty investor visas
• Reject all other visa categories, including general EADs
• Implement immediate SAVE verification before any license issuance

Mandatory Documentation:

• Require unexpired foreign passport
• Verify specific visa types through federal databases
• Conduct real-time immigration status checks using SAVE system
• Obtain federal confirmation before proceeding with any application

Process Changes:

• Eliminate limited-term licenses that extend beyond visa expiration dates
• Require annual in-person renewals only
• Institute immediate license revocation when visas expire
• End mail or online renewal options for non-domicile CDLs

Technology Infrastructure Needs

California would need to upgrade its DMV systems to:

• Interface directly with federal SAVE databases in real-time
• Automatically flag expired or invalid visa statuses
• Track visa expiration dates and trigger license suspensions
• Prevent issuance of licenses extending beyond authorized presence

Compliance Timeline Challenges

The 30-day compliance deadline poses significant challenges:

• Reviewing approximately 25% of existing non-domicile CDLs (potentially thousands of licenses)
• Training DMV staff on new verification procedures
• Updating computer systems to prevent future violations
• Coordinating with federal databases for real-time verification

Immediate Actions Required:

1. Pause all non-domicile CDL issuance
2. Audit existing licenses for compliance violations
3. Revoke improperly issued licenses
4. Submit corrective action plan to FMCSA

The reforms would essentially transform California's process from a document-based system to a real-time federal verification system, requiring significant technological and procedural overhauls to meet the emergency rule's safety and security objectives.

---

Sources

1. FreightWaves. "FMCSA issues emergency rule restricting non-domiciled CDLs." September 26, 2025. https://www.freightwaves.com/news/fmcsa-issues-emergency-rule-restricting-non-domiciled-cdls
2. Trucking Dive. "DOT emergency rule overhauls non-domiciled CDL issuances." September 25, 2025. https://www.truckingdive.com/news/dot-fmcsa-emergency-rule-nondomiciled-cdl-eligibility/761217/
3. Federal Motor Carrier Safety Administration. "Trump's Transportation Secretary Sean P. Duffy Takes Emergency Action to Protect America's Roads, Restrict Non-Domiciled CDLs." September 26, 2025. https://www.fmcsa.dot.gov/newsroom/trumps-transportation-secretary-sean-p-duffy-takes-emergency-action-protect-americas-roads
4. Overdrive. "FMCSA to force nearly 200K non-domiciled CDL holders out of trucking." September 26, 2025. https://www.overdriveonline.com/regulations/article/15767991/fmcsa-to-force-nearly-200k-nondomiciled-cdl-holders-out-of-trucking
5. CNS Protects. "Immediate Emergency Safety Reforms for Non-Domiciled CDLs." September 26, 2025. https://www.cnsprotects.com/news/emergency-changes-for-non-domicile-cdls/
6. CNN. "Truck drivers from outside the US face new license restrictions as DOT threatens to withhold money from California." September 26, 2025. https://www.cnn.com/2025/09/26/us/truck-driver-license-restrictions
7. Transport Topics. "DOT Tightens Rules for Noncitizen Truck Drivers." September 26, 2025. https://www.ttnews.com/articles/dot-rules-noncitizen-drivers
8. ABC News. "What to know about the stricter rules coming to noncitizen truck drivers after fatal Florida crash." September 26, 2025. https://abcnews.go.com/US/wireStory/stricter-rules-coming-noncitizen-truck-drivers-after-fatal-125985804
9. Transportation Security Administration. "Transportation Worker Identification Credential (TWIC)." https://www.tsa.gov/twic
10. Wayfindr. "US Truck Driver Shortage 2025: How It Impacts Global Supply Logistics." September 2025. https://wayfindr.io/blogs/why-us-truck-driver-shortage-matter-global-logistics/
11. Weber Logistics. "Reasons for drayage truck driver shortage and how the right 3PL can help." August 12, 2021. https://www.weberlogistics.com/blog/california-logistics-blog/reasons-drayage-truck-driver-shortage
12. Land Line. "Driver shortage not the problem, Port of L.A. director says." March 16, 2022. https://landline.media/driver-shortage-not-the-problem-port-of-l-a-director-says/
13. TIME. "The Great American Trucker Shortage Isn't Real." November 12, 2021. https://time.com/6116853/truck-driver-shortage-supply-chain/
14. FinditParts. "Truck Driver Shortage Statistics: 49 Trends You Should Know [2025]." March 17, 2025. https://www.finditparts.com/blog/truck-driver-shortage-statistics
15. FreightWaves. "Truckers tired of taking blame for congestion crisis at California ports." January 4, 2022. https://www.freightwaves.com/news/truckers-tired-of-taking-blame-for-congestion-crisis-at-california-ports