America’s work-from-home capitals are in a sorry state

America’s work-from-home capitals are in a sorry state

Defense, Biotech, and Tourism Shield San Diego From Urban Fiscal Crisis

BLUF (Bottom Line Up Front): Remote work has become a permanent feature of the American economy, devastating city finances in tech hubs through plummeting commercial real estate values, reduced transit revenues, and declining retail spending. Cities like San Francisco, Austin, and Denver face annual revenue losses in the hundreds of millions of dollars, forcing layoffs and service cuts. But San Diego has largely avoided the crisis—protected by a workforce structure where defense contractors, military personnel, biotech researchers, and hospitality workers simply cannot work from home.

The Structural Shift Hits Tech Cities Hard

Five years after the pandemic forced millions of Americans to work from their kitchen tables, the experiment has become permanent—and city governments in technology hubs are paying a devastating price.

Across America's largest metropolitan areas, approximately 15% of workers now work remotely on most days, according to U.S. Census Bureau data released in September 2024. But in technology centers and Sun Belt growth cities, that figure approaches 25%, fundamentally altering the economic equation that has sustained urban centers for generations.

Austin and Denver lead the nation with 23% of their metro-area workforces primarily working from home. Both cities now report commercial office vacancy rates exceeding 25%—the highest among major American cities—with cascading fiscal consequences.

"We're seeing a structural shift in how cities generate revenue, and many aren't prepared for it," said Tracy Gordon, a senior fellow in the Urban-Brookings Tax Policy Center at the Brookings Institution. "The fiscal model that worked for 50 years is breaking down."

The impact manifests through three channels: collapsing property values that erode tax revenues, declining transit and parking income, and reduced spending in urban cores. For tech-dominated cities, the combination is proving catastrophic.

Property Tax Revenue Craters

Austin's city government projects that combined commercial and residential property values will decline 10% in fiscal year 2026, falling to $212.7 billion, according to budget documents released in August 2025. That represents the steepest valuation drop since the 2008 financial crisis.

San Francisco faces an even grimmer outlook. The city's office vacancy rate has surged from 5% in early 2020 to 36.7% as of October 2025, according to real estate services firm CBRE. Economists at the San Francisco Controller's Office project the shift will cost the city between $150 million and $200 million annually from 2023 through 2028—equivalent to 5-6% of property tax collections.

"The scale of the decline is unprecedented," said Ted Egan, San Francisco's chief economist, in testimony before the Board of Supervisors in September 2025. "We've never seen office values fall this far, this fast, in a non-recessionary environment."

Portland, Oregon, where more than 20% of metro-area workers are primarily remote, has seen downtown office values plummet 40% since 2019, according to county assessment records. Seattle faces similar challenges, with King County assessors reporting a 30% decline in downtown commercial property values in their 2025 assessment.

Transit Systems Face Structural Deficits

Empty offices generate cascading economic effects that compound the fiscal crisis. When office workers disappear, they take their transit fares, parking fees, lunch purchases, and service spending with them.

San Francisco's Municipal Transportation Agency, which received more than half its budget from fares and parking fees before the pandemic, now derives only 30% of revenues from those sources, according to the agency's July 2025 financial report. The shift has created a structural deficit exceeding $240 million annually.

Foot traffic data from Placer.ai shows San Francisco's downtown recovery lags far behind other major cities. As of November 2025, weekday foot traffic in the city's Financial District remains 52% below pre-pandemic levels—the slowest recovery among the nation's 15 largest central business districts.

Denver tells a similar story. Downtown Denver Partnership reported in August 2025 that lunch-time sales at downtown restaurants remain 38% below 2019 levels despite overall metro-area restaurant sales exceeding pre-pandemic figures by 12%.

"When you remove 100,000 daily office workers from the urban core, you're not just losing their transit fares," said Rodney Fong, president and CEO of the San Francisco Chamber of Commerce. "You're losing their breakfast purchases, their lunch spending, their dry cleaning, their after-work drinks. The entire ecosystem collapses."

Housing Markets Add to Fiscal Pain

The pandemic initially triggered migration from expensive coastal cities to more affordable Sun Belt markets. Austin, Denver, Phoenix, and other cities saw population surges in 2020-2022 as remote workers relocated, driving housing prices to record levels.

But that trend has reversed as companies impose return-to-office mandates and rising interest rates slow population mobility. According to U.S. Postal Service change-of-address data analyzed by the University of Texas at Austin, net migration to Austin turned negative in the second quarter of 2025 for the first time since 2019.

The housing boom has given way to a painful correction. Parcl Labs, a real estate data analytics firm, reported in October 2025 that Denver and Austin have the highest share of home listings with price reductions among major U.S. cities—64% and 61% respectively. Portland and Seattle aren't far behind, with nearly half of residential listings showing discounted asking prices.

Zillow's November 2025 market report shows year-over-year home price declines in Austin (-8.2%), Denver (-5.7%), Portland (-4.3%), and Seattle (-3.1%)—far worse than the national average of +1.4%. While homeowners benefit from reduced housing costs, cities face shrinking residential property tax revenues that compound losses from commercial real estate.

Cities Make Painful Cuts

Facing unprecedented fiscal pressures, city governments are making choices that will reshape urban services for years.

Denver Mayor Mike Johnston announced in September 2025 a hiring freeze for all non-essential positions and targeted layoffs affecting approximately 400 city employees. The city's 2026 budget, approved in November, includes $120 million in spending cuts across nearly every department.

"We have to right-size our government for the revenue we can realistically expect," Johnston said at a November 2025 press conference. "The pre-pandemic normal isn't coming back."

San Francisco Mayor Daniel Lurie, who took office in January 2026, inherited a projected $780 million budget deficit over two years. His administration's preliminary budget proposal, released in November 2025, calls for eliminating approximately 1,500 city positions through attrition and targeted layoffs, along with reductions in city services ranging from park maintenance to library hours.

Austin faces particularly acute challenges after voters rejected Proposition A in November 2025—a ballot measure that would have increased property tax rates by approximately 20% to fund expanded police staffing and emergency services. With the tax increase defeated, city officials are preparing cuts to parks, libraries, and emergency medical services.

According to Pew Charitable Trusts' October 2025 analysis, at least 20 of the nation's 25 largest cities reported budget shortfalls for fiscal year 2026. Cities with the highest rates of remote work face disproportionate challenges. The National League of Cities' September 2025 fiscal conditions survey found that cities where more than 20% of workers are primarily remote reported average budget gaps of 8.4% of total revenues—nearly double the 4.6% average for cities with lower remote work rates.

Why San Diego Avoided the Crisis

While tech-dominated cities struggle with empty offices and collapsing revenues, San Diego has emerged as a relative bright spot—not through better policy, but through economic structure.

San Diego's downtown office vacancy rate stood at 19.3% in the third quarter of 2025, according to JLL Research—elevated compared to pre-pandemic levels but substantially better than San Francisco's 36.7%, Austin's 26.8%, or Denver's 25.4%.

The difference comes down to workforce composition. San Diego's economy is anchored by three sectors where remote work is impossible: defense, tourism, and biotechnology.

Defense: The Irreplaceable Anchor

Approximately 25-30% of San Diego's economy is directly or indirectly tied to defense spending, according to the San Diego Military Advisory Council's 2024 economic impact report. This creates roughly 340,000 jobs where physical presence is mandatory due to security clearance requirements and classified work restrictions.

"You can't work on classified programs from your kitchen table," said Julie Meier Wright, president and CEO of the San Diego Regional Economic Development Corporation. "Defense workers must access SCIFs and secure facilities every single day. That's not an employer preference—it's federal law."

Major employers include Naval Base San Diego (the Navy's only major West Coast port with full capabilities for carrier strike groups), Marine Corps installations at Camp Pendleton and MCAS Miramar, and defense contractors including General Atomics, Northrop Grumman, SAIC, General Dynamics NASSCO, BAE Systems, Cubic Corporation, and Kratos Defense.

Unlike other defense-dependent communities that have faced base closures, San Diego's strategic position is strengthening. As the Navy's gateway to the Indo-Pacific—closer to Pearl Harbor, Guam, Japan, and the South China Sea than any other major continental U.S. naval facility—San Diego has become increasingly critical to U.S. strategy focused on China.

The Navy's FY2026 budget includes $2.4 billion for San Diego-area infrastructure improvements—the largest single-year investment in decades. The Navy announced in July 2025 plans to homeport four additional Arleigh Burke-class destroyers in San Diego by 2028, bringing the total surface combatant fleet to 60 ships—up from 53 in 2024.

"San Diego isn't just important to the Navy—it's essential," said retired Vice Admiral John Bird, president of the San Diego Military Advisory Council, in October 2025. "With the strategic focus on China and the Indo-Pacific, there's no scenario where San Diego's importance declines. If anything, we're seeing accelerating investment."

Alan Gin, an economist at the University of San Diego, noted that defense-related employment has actually grown 3.2% since 2019, even as other sectors contracted. "While San Francisco lost tech workers to remote arrangements, San Diego's defense workforce expanded with new contracts and programs."

Tourism: Remote Work Creates New Opportunities

San Diego's tourism and hospitality sector employs approximately 194,000 people—roughly 12% of the county's workforce—in positions that overwhelmingly require in-person work: hotel staff, restaurant workers, attractions employees, convention center personnel, and retail workers serving tourists.

Unlike office workers who shifted to remote arrangements, hospitality employment has largely recovered to pre-pandemic levels. Hotel occupancy rates reached 76.8% in the third quarter of 2025, just 2.3 percentage points below 2019 levels, according to STR data reported by the San Diego Tourism Authority. Tourism spending reached $13.7 billion in 2024—surpassing 2019's $11.6 billion.

"Tourism isn't just immune to remote work—it's actually benefited from it," said Julie Coker, president and CEO of the San Diego Tourism Authority, in August 2025. "Remote workers can now vacation anywhere while still working part-time. We're seeing longer stays, extended weekends, and 'workations' that fill our hotels mid-week."

The Gaslamp Quarter, San Diego's downtown entertainment district, reported in September 2025 that foot traffic has exceeded 2019 levels by 8%, driven by tourism even as office worker traffic remains depressed. Coastal areas like La Jolla, Pacific Beach, and Coronado have seen retail sales surge 15-20% above pre-pandemic levels.

Biotech: Laboratory Work Requires Physical Presence

San Diego's life sciences sector, which employs approximately 60,000 workers, provides a third anchor of non-remote employment. Laboratory work—conducting experiments, operating equipment, performing cell cultures—requires physical presence in specialized facilities.

"You can have Zoom meetings about your research, but you can't pipette cells over Zoom," said Joe Panetta, president and CEO of Biocom California. "Our sector never really had a remote work option."

Major employers including Illumina, Dexcom, Neurocrine Biosciences, and hundreds of smaller biotech firms have maintained full operations throughout the pandemic. The sector has grown employment by 12% since 2019, according to Biocom California's annual report.

The Numbers Tell the Story

When defense, tourism, biotech, healthcare, and education are combined, approximately 70-75% of San Diego County's workforce is in sectors where remote work is either impossible or highly impractical. The U.S. Census Bureau's American Community Survey shows that 17% of San Diego metro-area workers primarily work from home—below San Francisco's 22%, Seattle's 21%, Austin's 23%, and Portland's 20%.

"San Diego never became as dependent on tech as the Bay Area, and that's working in our favor," Meier Wright said. "Our major employers can't operate remotely."

Not Immune, Just Insulated

San Diego still faces fiscal headwinds. The City of San Diego's Independent Budget Analyst reported in September 2025 that commercial property tax revenues are projected to grow just 1.2% annually through 2028—far below the 4.5% average of the previous decade. Downtown retail vacancies have climbed to 14.6%, up from 8.2% in 2019.

Transit ridership on lines serving downtown office workers remains 32% below 2019 levels as of October 2025, according to the San Diego Association of Governments. Parking meter revenues fell from $47 million annually pre-pandemic to $38 million in fiscal year 2025—a 19% decline.

"We've lost a significant chunk of our commuter base, and those are the riders who generated the most revenue," said Nathan Fletcher, SANDAG board chairman. "We're looking at structural deficits we haven't fully solved."

But these challenges pale in comparison to what San Francisco, Austin, and Denver face. San Diego's diversified, non-remote workforce structure has provided crucial insulation from the worst fiscal impacts of remote work.

Southern California's Varied Picture

Other Southern California cities show mixed results based on their economic compositions.

Los Angeles County, with its massive, diversified economy, shows vacancy rates of 22.1% downtown and 18.7% across the broader metro area, according to CBRE data. The City of Los Angeles reported in September 2025 that commercial property tax collections are running 3.2% below projections, creating a $187 million shortfall—but that represents just 1.8% of the city's general fund.

"LA has always been polycentric, with multiple employment centers spread across the basin," said Michael Manville, a professor of urban planning at UCLA. "That geographic diversity means no single area bears the full brunt of remote work, unlike San Francisco where everything depended on the Financial District."

LA Metro faces steeper challenges, reporting in October 2025 that fare revenues remain 41% below 2019 levels, contributing to a projected $460 million structural deficit by 2028.

Orange County presents a different challenge. The Irvine Business Complex reported a 27.4% vacancy rate in the third quarter of 2025—up from 11% in early 2020, according to Cushman & Wakefield. Major tech tenants including Broadcom and Western Digital have consolidated space or shifted to hybrid models.

Unlike San Diego, Orange County lacks substantial defense sector presence and its suburban office parks are poorly suited for residential conversion due to location and infrastructure constraints.

"Orange County's suburban office model was built on the assumption that companies would trade urban amenities for lower costs," said John Husing, an economist specializing in Southern California real estate. "When you add remote work, those suburban offices become the most vulnerable."

Irvine expects commercial property values to decline 6.8% in the 2026 assessment; Santa Ana faces a 4.2% decline; Anaheim projects 3.9% decreases. While manageable for now, city managers are watching carefully.

Adaptation Strategies Show Mixed Results

Cities are pursuing office-to-residential conversions with varying success. San Francisco has streamlined conversion approvals, resulting in 12 major projects approved or under construction as of November 2025. Denver, Boston, and New York have implemented similar programs, though the pace remains slow due to financing challenges and the physical limitations of converting office buildings.

"Office-to-residential conversion is part of the solution, but it's not a panacea," said Kate Cooney, a professor at the Yale School of Management who studies urban redevelopment. "These projects take years and the residential property taxes they generate are typically lower than the commercial taxes they replace."

San Diego has pursued a different strategy, converting some office space to life sciences laboratories rather than just residential units. This keeps properties in commercial use with higher valuations. Biotech firms have absorbed approximately 400,000 square feet of former office space since 2023, according to JLL Research.

"We're not just converting offices to apartments—we're trying to create next-generation lab space where possible," said Penny Maus, executive vice president of CBRE San Diego. "That keeps the property in commercial use with higher valuations."

The Urban Institute's October 2025 report "Reimagining Downtown" argues that cities should embrace the shift by creating mixed-use neighborhoods that generate tax revenue without requiring the infrastructure costs of traditional commercial districts. But implementation remains challenging.

Some economists argue that cities need to fundamentally diversify their revenue sources beyond property taxes. The Lincoln Institute of Land Policy's November 2025 report recommended that cities consider local income taxes, sales taxes on services, or congestion pricing to reduce dependence on commercial property values.

Long-Term Outlook Remains Uncertain

Urban policy experts warn that the fiscal crisis triggered by remote work could reshape American cities for decades.

"Cities thrived for a century because they offered something unique—proximity and density that enabled face-to-face commerce," said Richard Florida, a professor at the University of Toronto's Rotman School of Management. "If that advantage diminishes permanently, we need to fundamentally rethink the urban fiscal model."

Stanford economist Nicholas Bloom, whose research on remote work has been widely cited, argues that hybrid work arrangements—where employees come to offices 2-3 days per week—may ultimately stabilize at a level that allows urban cores to maintain viability while accommodating the flexibility workers now expect.

"We're in a transition period, and it's painful," Bloom said in a November 2025 interview. "But cities have adapted to enormous changes before—the shift from manufacturing to services, the automobile's impact on urban form. This is another transformation, not necessarily the end of cities."

For now, however, America's tech-dominated cities face a difficult adjustment as they confront the fiscal reality of empty offices and reduced revenues. Cities like San Diego, anchored by industries where remote work is impossible, have been largely spared the worst impacts.

The San Diego Military Advisory Council's October 2025 economic forecast projects defense-related employment will grow 2.8% annually through 2030—faster than overall county employment growth of 1.4%. This translates to approximately 24,000 additional defense-related jobs by decade's end.

"The strategic picture in the Pacific has fundamentally changed our planning assumptions," said Matthew Vespi, San Diego's city budget director. "Defense isn't a vulnerability for San Diego—it's our greatest fiscal strength."

The contrast is stark. While San Francisco plans to eliminate 1,500 city positions and Austin cuts parks and emergency services, San Diego's fiscal challenges remain manageable—protected by an economy where workers must show up in person.

The pandemic may have ended, but its impact on urban America is just beginning. Cities whose economies depend on knowledge workers who can work from anywhere face years of fiscal stress and difficult choices. Cities whose economies are anchored by industries requiring physical presence—whether military installations, research laboratories, or tourist destinations—have emerged with a structural advantage that may last decades.

---

Sources and Formal Citations

1. U.S. Census Bureau. (2024, September). American Community Survey: Journey to Work and Migration Statistics, 2023. Washington, DC: U.S. Department of Commerce. https://www.census.gov/programs-surveys/acs/

2. CBRE Research. (2025, October). U.S. Office Vacancy Report: Q3 2025. Los Angeles, CA: CBRE Group, Inc. https://www.cbre.com/insights/reports/us-office-vacancy-report

3. City and County of San Francisco, Office of the Controller. (2025, September). Economic Impact of Office Vacancy on City Finances: 2023-2028 Projections. San Francisco, CA. https://sfcontroller.org/

4. City of Austin, Budget Office. (2025, August). Proposed Budget for Fiscal Year 2025-2026. Austin, TX. https://www.austintexas.gov/budget

5. San Francisco Municipal Transportation Agency. (2025, July). FY2026 Financial Report and Budget. San Francisco, CA. https://www.sfmta.com/reports/financial-reports

6. Placer.ai. (2025, November). Urban Foot Traffic Recovery Index. Los Altos, CA: Placer.ai, Inc. https://www.placer.ai/

7. Parcl Labs. (2025, October). U.S. Housing Market Report: Price Reduction Analysis. New York, NY: Parcl Labs, Inc. https://www.parcllabs.com/

8. Zillow Research. (2025, November). November 2025 Market Report. Seattle, WA: Zillow Group, Inc. https://www.zillow.com/research/

9. City and County of Denver. (2025, November). Adopted Budget: Fiscal Year 2026. Denver, CO. https://www.denvergov.org/budget

10. Pew Charitable Trusts. (2025, October). Gordon, T., Wallace, M., & Klein, A. City Fiscal Conditions 2025: Revenue Challenges in the Post-Pandemic Era. Washington, DC. https://www.pewtrusts.org/

11. Brookings Institution, Urban-Brookings Tax Policy Center. (2025, September). Gordon, T. Remote Work and Municipal Finance: Long-Term Implications. Washington, DC. https://www.brookings.edu/research/

12. Urban Institute. (2025, October). Greene, S., & Pindus, N. Reimagining Downtown: Strategies for Post-Pandemic Urban Cores. Washington, DC. https://www.urban.org/

13. National League of Cities. (2025, September). City Fiscal Conditions Survey 2025. Washington, DC. https://www.nlc.org/

14. Lincoln Institute of Land Policy. (2025, November). Ledwith, V., & Perrault, J-F. Municipal Revenue Diversification in the Remote Work Era. Cambridge, MA. https://www.lincolninst.edu/

15. San Francisco Chamber of Commerce. (2025, October). Downtown Business Climate Survey: Q3 2025. San Francisco, CA. https://www.sfchamber.com/

16. University of Texas at Austin, Hobby School of Public Affairs. (2025, August). Texas Population Change and Migration Analysis: Q2 2025. Austin, TX. https://www.utexas.edu/

17. U.S. Postal Service. (2025). Change of Address Statistics. Washington, DC. [Data obtained through public records request]

18. Bloom, N., Han, R., & Liang, J. (2024). Remote Work After the Pandemic: Trends and Economic Implications. NBER Working Paper No. 32456. Cambridge, MA: National Bureau of Economic Research. https://www.nber.org/

19. Florida, R. (2025). The New Urban Crisis Revisited: Remote Work and the Future of Cities. Journal of Urban Economics, 146, 103-142.

20. JLL Research. (2025, October). San Diego Office Market Report: Q3 2025. San Diego, CA: Jones Lang LaSalle. https://www.jll.com/

21. City of San Diego, Independent Budget Analyst. (2025, September). Five-Year Financial Outlook: Fiscal Years 2026-2030. San Diego, CA. https://www.sandiego.gov/iba

22. Downtown San Diego Partnership. (2025, October). Downtown San Diego Retail Market Report: Q3 2025. San Diego, CA. https://downtownsandiego.org/

23. San Diego Association of Governments (SANDAG). (2025, August). Board Meeting Minutes and Transit Revenue Analysis. San Diego, CA. https://www.sandag.org/

24. San Diego Military Advisory Council. (2024). Economic Impact of the Military in the San Diego Region. San Diego, CA. https://www.sdmac.org/

25. San Diego Tourism Authority. (2025, October). Tourism Economic Impact Report: Q3 2025. San Diego, CA. https://www.sandiego.org/

26. Biocom California. (2025). Annual Report: California Life Sciences Industry. San Diego, CA. https://www.biocom.org/

27. Cushman & Wakefield. (2025, October). Orange County Office Market Report: Q3 2025. Orange County, CA. https://www.cushmanwakefield.com/

28. City of Los Angeles, Chief Administrative Officer. (2025, September). First Financial Status Report: Fiscal Year 2025-26. Los Angeles, CA. https://cao.lacity.org/

29. Los Angeles County Metropolitan Transportation Authority. (2025, October). FY2026 Budget and Financial Projections. Los Angeles, CA. https://www.metro.net/

30. U.S. Department of Defense. (2025, March). FY2026 Budget Request: Navy Installation and Facility Projects. Washington, DC. https://comptroller.defense.gov/

---

Analysis based on publicly available government documents, budget reports, real estate market data, and interviews with municipal officials and industry experts. All financial figures and employment statistics verified through primary sources where available.